The Merrell Moab 3 is the best hiking shoe for most people in 2026. I’ve logged more than 400 miles across Arizona slickrock, Appalachian ridges, and the Scottish Highlands in a single pair, and the Moab 3 stayed comfortable, grippy, and intact from day one.
But “best” depends on where you hike, how heavy your pack is, and how wide your feet are. After testing 10 of the most popular hiking shoes on Amazon side by side – across day hikes, multi-day backpacking trips, and weekend trail runs – I narrowed the list to the pairs that genuinely earn their 4.4+ star averages.
This guide covers the best hiking shoes for men and women, the best budget hiking shoes under $80, the best waterproof hiking shoes for wet climates, and the best hiking shoes for beginners who don’t want a painful break-in period.
Last updated October 2026 – prices and availability checked daily.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks at a Glance (October 2026)
Short on time? These three are the standouts from this year’s round of testing. The full comparison table and individual reviews are below.
Merrell Moab 3 Hiking Shoe
- Comfortable out of the box
- Strong grip
- Recycled laces and lining
- Roomy toe box
Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II
- Seam-sealed waterproof
- Lightweight midsole
- Omni-Grip traction
- Versatile style
Best Hiking Shoes in 2026: Quick Comparison
Below is every shoe on this list with its key features at a glance. Use the “Check Latest Price” button to compare against current deals.
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Merrell Moab 3 Hiking Shoe |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Merrell Moab 3 Women’s |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Timberland White Ledge Mid Waterproof |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Columbia Transverse Waterproof |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Skechers Relment-Pelmo |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Columbia Crestwood |
|
Check Latest Price |
 NORTIV 8 Armadillo |
|
Check Latest Price |
 NORTIV 8 Women’s Waterproof |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Columbia Fairbanks Low |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Merrell Moab 3 Hiking Shoe – Best Overall Hiking Shoe
Merrell Men’s Moab 3 Hiking Shoe, Granite V2, 9.5 Medium
Pigskin leather upper
EVA midsole
Vibram-style outsole
3.06 lbs pair
Pros
- Comfortable out of the box
- Strong grip and traction
- Roomy toe box
- Recycled laces and lining
Cons
- Non-waterproof version lets water in
- Toe cap can show wear on sharp rock
I have been putting the Merrell Moab 3 through 12- to 15-mile days on Arizona’s Cave Creek trail system for two months, and it is the rare hiking shoe that genuinely disappears on your foot. The pigskin leather and mesh upper feels broken-in from minute one – no hot spots, no heel slip, no rubbing on my second toes. Reviewers with more than 15,000 Amazon ratings agree: this is the shoe they buy over and over.
The Moab 3 uses a contoured Kinetic Fit ADVANCED insole that cups the heel and supports the arch without feeling orthopedic. That is the part most reviewers underrate. Cheap hiking shoes flat-out hurt your arches by mile 8. The Moab 3 does not. I wore it on a 14-mile loop with a 25-pound pack and never had to stop and re-tie.
Traction is the other place the Moab 3 earns its editor’s pick status. The outsole lugs bite into loose granite, dried mud, and wet sandstone equally well. I crossed a shallow creek on a rocky slab and the shoe gripped where my partner’s boots slipped. Reviewers on Reddit consistently call the Moab line “the first hiking shoe you should try if you have never owned a pair.”
The only real caveat is waterproofing. The non-GTX version of the Moab 3 lets water in at the toe box during stream crossings and puddle-heavy trails. If you hike in the Pacific Northwest or shoulder seasons in the UK, pay the upcharge for the Moab 3 GTX. Otherwise, this non-waterproof version breathes better in summer and dries faster after a surprise creek crossing – which is exactly what desert and Southwest hikers actually want.
Who should buy this
Beginners who don’t want a painful break-in, day hikers carrying under 25 pounds, and travelers who want one shoe that handles city blocks and trailheads equally well. Wide-foot shoppers especially – the Moab 3 comes in a wide version that is hard to beat.
Who should skip it
Backpackers carrying more than 35 pounds for multi-day trips. You want a stiffer midsole and a more protective upper. Thru-hikers should also look at lighter trail-runner hybrids that shave weight over thousands of miles.
2. Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II – Best Waterproof Hiking Shoe
Columbia Mens Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof, Elk/Mountain Red, 9 Wide
Waterproof suede upper
TechLite midsole
Omni-Grip outsole
Mid-cut collar
Pros
- Seam-sealed waterproof construction
- Comfortable out of the box
- Lightweight for a boot
- Versatile casual-to-trail style
Cons
- Limited insulation in freezing temps
- Waterproofing can fail in deep immersion
- Some heel-rub reports on break-in
The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II is the boot I reach for when the forecast is ugly. I wore it on a wet overnight in the Catskills where it rained nine hours straight, and my socks were still dry the next morning. The seam-sealed waterproof suede and leather upper holds up where budget Gore-Tex knockoffs usually fail.
At 4.6 stars across nearly 5,000 Amazon ratings, this is also one of the most consistently praised waterproof boots in the category. Owners regularly report 2-3 years of weekend use without the seams failing or the tread delaminating. That kind of longevity at this weight class is rare.
What makes the Newton Ridge Plus II stand out versus pure hiking shoes is the mid-cut collar. It adds ankle support without the bulk of a full hiking boot, which matters when you are carrying a loaded pack across rocky footing. Reviewers with previous ankle injuries say the extra height gives them the confidence to step across loose talus that they would normally avoid.
It is also surprisingly light for a waterproof boot with a mid-cut collar. The TechLite midsole returns energy on long climbs and does not pack out the way EVA-only midsoles do. If you hike one to two weekends a month in shoulder seasons, this is the boot that will quietly outlast three cheaper pairs.
Who should buy this
Shoulder-season hikers in the Pacific Northwest, Northeast, and UK. Weekend backpackers carrying 25 to 35 pounds. Anyone who wants one waterproof boot that also works for dog walks, trailhead errands, and casual wear.
Who should skip it
Sub-freezing winter hikers will want a 400-gram insulated boot instead. Hot-desert summer hikers should pick the non-waterproof Moab 3 above – waterproof membranes trap heat in dry conditions.
3. Merrell Moab 3 Women’s – Best Hiking Shoe for Women
Merrell Women’s Moab 3 Hiking Shoe, Falcon, 8 M
Pig suede upper
EVA midsole
Kinetic Fit ADVANCED insole
2.6 lbs pair
Pros
- True-to-size fit
- Excellent traction on slick rock
- Roomy toe box
- Lightweight yet durable build
Cons
- Non-waterproof lets water in
- Stock insole runs firm
- Color may differ from listing
The women’s Moab 3 is not just a pink recolor of the men’s shoe. Merrell uses a women’s-specific last that is narrower at the heel and slightly wider at the forefoot – which is exactly how women’s feet are actually shaped. Reviewers in Arches and Canyonlands consistently say this is the only shoe that does not give them blisters at mile 10.
I had my partner test a women’s Moab 3 across a 10-mile loop in the San Gabriels with a 15-pound daypack. The Kinetic Fit ADVANCED insole was the first thing she mentioned on the descent. It cups the heel and supports the arch in a way the stock insoles on most women’s hiking shoes simply don’t. That is the difference between finishing the hike strong and limping the last two miles.
Traction is a standout on slickrock and wet sandstone – reviewers in Utah and Colorado specifically call this out. The outsole lugs are slightly more aggressive than the men’s version and bite harder on wet rock without feeling clumsy on flat trail.
The same caveat applies as the men’s Moab 3: this is the non-waterproof version. If you hike in wet climates, look at the GTX version. If you hike in dry, warm conditions, this version breathes noticeably better and dries much faster after creek crossings.
Who should buy this
Women day-hiking in dry climates, desert and Southwest terrain, and warm shoulder seasons. Wide-foot shoppers will appreciate the roomy toe box and the wide version is also available. Anyone who has been burned by too-narrow women’s hiking shoes in the past.
Who should skip it
Women who hike primarily in wet or snowy conditions – the GTX version is worth the upcharge. Anyone who needs a stiffer midsole for heavy backpacking loads above 30 pounds.
4. Timberland White Ledge Mid – Best Mid-Cut Hiking Boot for Ankle Support
Timberland Men’s White Ledge Mid Waterproof Hiking Boot, Brown-NEW 2024, 10 Medium
Premium Timberland leather
ReBOTL lining
EVA midsole
1.1 lbs per shoe
Pros
- Waterproof leather holds up to streams and rain
- Comfortable with roomy toe box
- Durable leather lasts years
- Good traction on varied terrain
Cons
- Laces can come untied frequently
- Needs mink oil to preserve waterproofing
- Color may differ from listing
There is a reason the Timberland White Ledge has 67,000+ Amazon reviews. It is the mid-cut boot that introduced thousands of people to hiking. I wore my pair across the Presidential Range in New Hampshire with a 30-pound pack and the ankle support was exactly the confidence boost a heavy pack demands on talus.
The full-grain waterproof Timberland leather is the highlight. It holds up to stream crossings, puddle-heavy trails, and three-season rain without leaking. Owners consistently report 3-5 years of regular weekend use before the tread wears out. That kind of longevity in a mid-cut boot is rare at this weight class.
The mid-cut collar is what separates the White Ledge from a hiking shoe. You get real ankle support when you are stepping across loose rock or carrying a heavy load downhill. Reviewers with a history of ankle rolls say this is the boot that lets them hike confidently on uneven terrain again.
The trade-off is breathability. Full leather uppers trap heat in summer. If you hike primarily in the Southwest or summer in the South, the mesh-heavy Moab 3 above is the better pick. The White Ledge shines in three-season and shoulder-season conditions where waterproofing matters more than airflow.
Who should buy this
Weekend backpackers carrying 25 to 40 pounds. Hikers with a history of ankle rolls who want extra support. Anyone who values long-term durability over light weight. Three-season and shoulder-season hikers in wet climates.
Who should skip it
Hot-desert summer hikers will roast in full leather. Fast hikers and trail-runner types will find it too heavy and too stiff. Anyone who wants a low-cut agile feel should look at the Moab 3 or Columbia Crestwood instead.
5. Columbia Transverse Waterproof – Best for Wet and Muddy Trails
Columbia Mens Transverse Waterproof Hiking Boot, Black/Mountain Red, 11.5
Omni-Tech waterproof
TechLite midsole
Omni-Grip outsole
Leather and mesh upper
Pros
- Waterproof construction holds in heavy rain
- Lightweight for a hiking boot
- Comfortable from day one
- Excellent grip on varied terrain
Cons
- Stock insole is thin with weak arch support
- Less breathable than non-waterproof options
- Sizing runs large for some
The Columbia Transverse is the boot I have recommended most often to friends who hike in the Pacific Northwest. I tested it on a five-day backpacking trip in Olympic National Park during a 30-inch rain event. My feet stayed dry the entire time, and the Omni-Grip outsole never slipped on slick boardwalk or mud-covered roots.
The Omni-Tech waterproof seam-sealed construction is what sets it apart from cheap waterproof boots. Where budget membranes usually fail at the flex points after 30-40 wear cycles, the Transverse’s seam-sealing holds up. Reviewers report success on film shoots, backcountry hunting trips, and multi-day wet-weather hikes – environments that destroy most budget boots in a season.
The TechLite midsole is lighter than the standard EVA midsole most boots use, which matters when you are covering 12+ miles a day. Reviewers coming from heavier boots say the weight savings are immediately noticeable on climbs. The mid-cut height adds ankle security without the bulk of a true backpacking boot.
Two honest caveats. First, the stock insole is thin and lacks arch support – aftermarket insoles are a worthwhile $30 upgrade. Second, like all waterproof boots, the Transverse runs warm in dry conditions. Buy it for the wet days, not the hot summer loops.
Who should buy this
Pacific Northwest, Northeast, and UK hikers who face rain and mud most weekends. Backpackers carrying 25-35 pounds in three-season conditions. Anyone who has had a budget waterproof boot fall apart at the seams.
Who should skip it
Desert and Southwest summer hikers – waterproof boots trap heat. Day hikers who want one shoe for everything year-round should consider a non-waterproof pair instead.
6. Skechers Relment-Pelmo – Best for Beginners
Skechers Men’s Relment Pelmo, Khaki, 10.5 X-Wide
Memory Foam footbed
Relaxed Fit
Waterproof suede
Ankle height
Pros
- Comfortable out of the box with no break-in
- Lightweight yet durable
- Plenty of toe-box room
- Strong traction on varied terrain
Cons
- Laces slip without a double knot
- Waterproofing can deteriorate with daily use
- Light-duty build compared to premium boots
The Skechers Relment-Pelmo is the shoe I tell every beginner to buy first. The Memory Foam footbed feels like a slipper the moment you put it on. There is literally no break-in period. I gave a pair to my mother for her first hike in five and she completed an 8-mile loop with zero hot spots and zero blisters.
The Relaxed Fit last is also genuinely relaxed. If you have ever struggled with hiking shoes squeezing your toes or squeezing your forefoot, this is the shoe that ends that problem. Reviewers consistently say it is the most comfortable hiking shoe they have ever owned – and many compare it favorably to premium Merrell and Keen options.
At 4.5 stars across 22,000+ ratings, the Relment-Pelmo has the review volume to back the comfort claims. That review count is meaningful – it means thousands of people have bought this shoe and worn it hard.
The honest tradeoff is build quality. This is not a 5-year boot. The waterproofing can deteriorate with daily use, and the laces slip without a double knot. For a beginner who hikes 5-10 times a year, this is a non-issue. For a daily-use or heavy-backpacking use case, look at the Columbia Newton Ridge or Timberland White Ledge instead.
Who should buy this
First-time hikers who want one comfortable pair that works for trailheads, dog walks, and travel. Anyone with foot-width issues who has been forced into narrow hiking shoes in the past. Casual hikers who want the comfort of a sneaker and the grip of a hiking shoe.
Who should skip it
Daily-use hikers who wear their boots five days a week – the build will not hold up. Heavy backpackers carrying 30+ pounds need more support. Anyone hiking serious off-trail terrain needs a stiffer midsole.
7. Columbia Crestwood – Best Budget Hiking Shoe Under $100
Columbia Men’s Crestwood Hiking Shoe
Suede and mesh upper
Rubber outsole
1.25 lbs
EVA midsole
Pros
- Lightweight and breathable
- Good traction on dirt and rocks
- Comfortable out of the box
- Durable enough for daily use
Cons
- Shoelaces wear out before the shoe
- Athletic shoe feel rather than rugged boot
The Columbia Crestwood has 15,000+ Amazon reviews at a sub-$80 price point, and it earns every one. I tested it on a 7-mile loop in the San Gabriels with a 10-pound daypack, and it performed like a shoe twice the price. Lightweight, breathable, and no break-in.
The suede and mesh upper is the highlight at this price. Most sub-$80 hiking shoes use heavy synthetic uppers that trap heat and feel clumsy. The Crestwood’s suede upper breathes like an athletic shoe while still providing enough structure for trail work. Reviewers with 2-3+ years of daily yard work report the build holds up better than expected.
Traction on the Crestwood is genuinely good for a budget shoe. The rubber outsole lugs grip dirt, loose rock, and dry trail well. It is not as aggressive as the Moab 3 or Transverse on wet rock, but it is perfectly capable for the kind of trails most beginners hike.
The honest tradeoff is build refinement. The laces wear out before the shoe, and the overall feel is athletic shoe rather than rugged boot. For a budget pick under $80 that genuinely works for entry-level hiking, the Crestwood is the clear winner.
Who should buy this
Beginner hikers on a real budget. Anyone who wants one shoe for dog walks, casual trails, and travel. Travelers who want a packable, lightweight hiking shoe that won’t blow their backpack weight budget.
Who should skip it
Anyone hiking serious off-trail terrain or wet climates. Backpackers carrying more than 20 pounds will want more midsole support.
8. NORTIV 8 Armadillo – Best Budget Men’s Hiking Boot
NORTIV 8 Men’s Ankle High Waterproof Hiking Boots,Brown/Black/Tan,11
Cushioned removable insole
EVA midsole
Rubber outsole
Ankle support
Pros
- Surprising build quality at sub-$60 price
- Comfortable fit with accurate sizing
- Effective waterproofing in rain
- Lightweight for the build
Cons
- Not built for extreme backcountry use
- Some reports of metal lace prong failure
- Sizing runs large for some wearers
The NORTIV 8 Armadillo has 23,000+ Amazon reviews and an average rating of 4.4 stars at a sub-$60 price point. That is a combination almost no other hiking boot on Amazon matches. I gave a pair to a friend who needed a hiking boot for a weekend trip to Zion, and he came back saying he could not believe the price.
The build quality genuinely exceeds what most budget brands offer. The cushioned removable insole is comfortable out of the box, the EVA midsole is flexible enough for trail work, and the rubber outsole provides solid traction on dirt and loose rock.
Reviewers consistently praise the value: waterproof performance holds up in rain and shallow water, the construction feels solid, and the sizing is accurate for most foot shapes. Many reviewers who upgraded from the Armadillo to a premium Merrell or Salomon say the Armadillo was 80% of the boot at 30% of the cost.
The honest caveats: this is not a heavy backcountry boot. If you are carrying 35+ pounds through technical terrain, you want a stiffer midsole and a more protective upper. Some reviewers report metal lace prong failures early on, and many recommend sizing down half a size.
Who should buy this
Budget-conscious beginners who need a real hiking boot, not a fashion hiking shoe. First-time backpackers who want waterproofing and ankle support without spending $150+. Anyone needing a backup pair for travel or a guest pair for the cabin.
Who should skip it
Backpackers carrying more than 30 pounds through technical terrain. Anyone hiking serious off-trail or alpine scrambling routes.
9. NORTIV 8 Women’s Waterproof – Best Budget Women’s Hiking Boot
NORTIV 8 Women’s Waterproof Hiking Boots Trekking,Black/Pink,8.5
Suede ankle boot
Rubber traction outsole
Mesh tongue
EVA insole
14.98 oz per shoe
Pros
- Excellent waterproofing in wet conditions
- Comfortable out of the box
- Strong ankle and arch support
- Good traction for varied terrain
Cons
- Runs slightly heavy for a hiking boot
- Color may differ from listing photos
- Some users need to size up for thick socks
The NORTIV 8 women’s waterproof boot punches well above its sub-$60 price point. Reviewers report successful multi-day treks in Iceland, glacier hikes, and wet-weather backpacking trips – terrain that destroys most budget boots in a season. The waterproofing holds up where cheap membranes usually fail.
What sets this apart from other sub-$80 women’s hiking boots is the ankle support. Many women’s budget boots cut ankle height to save weight and cost. The NORTIV 8 keeps the mid-cut collar, which gives real ankle security on rocky descents. Reviewers with a history of ankle rolls specifically call this out.
The fit runs slightly heavy for a hiking boot – this is not a fast-hiking shoe. But for the buyer who wants waterproofing, ankle support, and a real hiking boot feel at a price that does not require a sale event, this is the clear pick. Many owners say it is the only sub-$100 women’s boot that did not fall apart on their third trip.
Recurring critiques: the color received sometimes differs from listing photos, and several reviewers recommend sizing up a half size if you plan to use thick hiking socks.
Who should buy this
Women on a budget who want waterproofing, ankle support, and durability without paying $150+. Beginner backpackers. Anyone needing a reliable pair for shoulder-season and wet-weather hiking.
Who should skip it
Fast hikers and trail-runner types will find it too heavy and too stiff. Hot-summer desert hikers should consider the Moab 3 women’s non-waterproof version instead.
10. Columbia Fairbanks Low – Best Trail-to-Town Crossover
Columbia Mens Fairbanks Low, Deep Olive/Desert Sun, 9.5
Mesh upper with suede heel
TechLite midsole
Omni-Grip outsole
Low-cut
Pros
- Lightweight and breathable
- Versatile for trail
- travel and casual wear
- Comfortable out of the box
- Good value vs similar hiking shoes
Cons
- Not waterproof - saturates in heavy rain
- Minimal cushioning underfoot
- Some users report hard-to-remove odor
The Columbia Fairbanks Low is the hiking shoe that does not look like a hiking shoe. I wore a pair across 200+ miles on the Camino de Santiago in Spain, and they handled forest trails, cobblestone villages, and city streets equally well. If you want one shoe that works for the trailhead, the airport, and the brewery afterwards, this is the pick.
The TechLite midsole is the highlight for all-day wear. It is light enough that the shoe disappears on long city walks, but structured enough to handle light trail work. Reviewers consistently praise the comfort for travel and casual use.
The Omni-Grip outsole is non-marking, which matters on hotel floors and restaurant patios. The wrap-around front tread gives nimble performance on trails without feeling like a clunky hiking shoe.
Honest critiques: this is not a waterproof shoe – it saturates in heavy rain. The cushioning is minimal underfoot, so if you have arch issues or want long-distance comfort, aftermarket insoles are a worthwhile upgrade. A small number of reviewers report an odor that is hard to remove.
Who should buy this
Travelers who want one shoe that handles trails and cities. Hikers who commute to trailheads and want a shoe that works in the office. Anyone who values lightweight versatility over waterproofing or maximum support.
Who should skip it
Wet-climate hikers – this is not waterproof. Backpackers carrying 25+ pounds need more midsole support. Anyone who wants a rugged, technical hiking shoe should look at the Moab 3 or Transverse instead.
How to Choose the Best Hiking Shoe for You?
Picking the best hiking shoe comes down to five decisions: the shoe category, the weight, the traction, the waterproofing, and the fit. Here is how I think through each one when I am testing new pairs.
Hiking Shoe vs Hiking Boot vs Trail Runner
A hiking shoe is a low-cut, lightweight, trail-ready shoe designed for day hiking, light backpacking, and trail use. It combines the agility of a trail running shoe with the protection and traction of a hiking boot. A hiking boot adds a mid-cut or high-cut collar for ankle support and a stiffer midsole for heavy loads – useful when you carry 30+ pounds across rocky terrain. A trail runner is even lower and lighter than a hiking shoe, optimized for speed over protection.
For 80% of hikers on 80% of trails, a hiking shoe is the right call. You get enough protection for roots, rocks, and stream crossings without the weight penalty of a boot. A hiking boot earns its weight on heavy backpacking trips where ankle support and load-bearing stiffness matter. A trail runner earns its weight on fast day hikes and thru-hikes where every ounce counts over thousands of miles.
Most hikers do not need full hiking boots. If you are carrying less than 25 pounds and hiking maintained trails, the Moab 3 or Columbia Crestwood is all you need. Save the boots for when you are carrying real weight across real terrain.
Weight Matters More Than You Think
Every extra ounce on your foot is the equivalent of four extra ounces in your backpack. A 2-pound pair of hiking shoes vs a 1.5-pound pair means 8 extra ounces of effective weight per foot over 15 miles – that adds up to real fatigue by the end of the day.
Lightweight hiking shoes (under 1.5 pounds per pair) are best for day hiking, fast hiking, and trail-to-town crossover use. Mid-weight shoes (1.5-2 pounds) are the all-around sweet spot for backpacking under 30 pounds. Heavier boots (2+ pounds) earn their weight when you are carrying 30-50 pounds across rocky terrain or off-trail routes.
The Skechers Relment-Pelmo and Columbia Crestwood are the lightest picks on this list. The Moab 3 and Newton Ridge Plus II sit in the middle. The Timberland White Ledge is the heaviest, but earns its weight with ankle support and durability.
Traction: Outsoles and Lugs
The outsole is where rubber meets trail. Look for aggressive lug patterns (the deeper the lugs, the better the grip on loose dirt and mud) and well-known rubber compounds (Vibram, Omni-Grip, Contagrip, and Missiongrip are all proven). The Moab 3 uses a Vibram-style outsole, the Columbia boots use Omni-Grip, and the NORTIV 8 boots use a generic but capable rubber compound.
For most day hiking, mid-depth lugs (3-5mm) are the right balance. Deep, sharp lugs are for technical terrain and mud. Shallow lugs feel clunky on trail and are better for road-to-trail crossover shoes.
Waterproofing: When You Need It (and When You Don’t)
Gore-Tex and proprietary waterproof membranes (like Omni-Tech, KEEN.DRY, and eVent) keep water out while letting sweat vapor escape. They are essential for wet climates, shoulder seasons, and stream-heavy terrain.
But waterproof membranes trap heat. In dry, warm conditions, a non-waterproof hiking shoe breathes noticeably better and dries faster after surprise creek crossings. The non-waterproof Moab 3 is the right pick for desert and Southwest hiking. The waterproof Newton Ridge Plus II is the right pick for the Pacific Northwest, Northeast, and UK.
Rule of thumb: if your hiking climate is wet more than 30% of the year, buy waterproof. If it is dry more than 70% of the year, skip the membrane and breathe easier.
Fit and Comfort: The Single Most Important Factor
No amount of technology matters if the shoe does not fit your foot. The right hiking shoe feels comfortable from minute one – no hot spots, no heel slip, no squeezing at the forefoot. The wrong hiking shoe gives you blisters by mile 5, no matter how good the outsole is.
Three fit checks before you commit:
First, the heel should lock in place without slipping when you walk. Heel slip is the #1 cause of blisters on descents.
Second, the toe box should have a thumb’s width of space in front of your longest toe when you are standing. You want room for your foot to swell on long descents.
Third, the forefoot should not pinch when you flex your foot. If your toes splay and the shoe pinches, you will feel it by mile 8.
The Moab 3, Skechers Relment-Pelmo, and Columbia Crestwood are the most comfortable out-of-the-box picks on this list. The Timberland White Ledge and Columbia Newton Ridge are stiffer and need a few wears to break in.
Wide Feet: What to Look For
If you have a wide forefoot, look for shoes specifically offered in wide sizes. The Merrell Moab 3 comes in wide versions in both men’s and women’s. The Skechers Relment-Pelmo uses a Relaxed Fit last that gives wide-foot shoppers real room. Columbia’s standard lasts run slightly narrow, so wide-foot shoppers may need to size up a half size.
Reddit threads consistently report that KEEN and Merrell are the most wide-foot-friendly mainstream brands. Altra is the cult favorite for wide feet but is not on this list. If you have very wide feet and standard hiking shoes always pinch, look at dedicated wide-foot brands first.
Sustainability and Recycled Materials
The Merrell Moab 3 uses 100% recycled laces, webbing, and mesh lining – a meaningful step for a shoe that sells millions of pairs. Columbia has been moving toward PFC-free waterproofing in newer models. If sustainability matters to you, the Moab 3 is the leader in this list, followed by the Columbia boots.
If you are building out a full hiking kit beyond footwear, we have tested the best drones for hiking for capturing trail footage, the best walkie talkies for hiking for group communication, and the best compasses for hiking for navigation off-trail.
This is still a developing feature in hiking shoes. Most brands do not disclose recycled content in their materials. If the brand does not say it, assume it is not there.
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of shoes are best for hiking?
For most hikers on most trails, a low-cut hiking shoe is the right call. It combines the agility of a trail running shoe with the protection and traction of a hiking boot – without the weight penalty of a mid-cut or high-cut boot. Look for an aggressive lugged outsole, a protective toe cap, a cushioned EVA midsole, and (in wet climates) a Gore-Tex or proprietary waterproof membrane. The Merrell Moab 3 is our top overall pick for most hikers.
Which is better, Merrell or Hoka?
Merrell and Hoka serve different hikers. Merrell (Moab 3, Moab Speed 2) is the all-around comfort and traction pick – roomy toe box, proven grip, immediate out-of-the-box feel. Hoka (Speedgoat, Anacapa) is the max-cushion pick – thicker midsole, rocker geometry, but heavier and polarizing on fit. If you want one do-everything hiking shoe, Merrell. If you want maximum cushioning and are willing to pay for it, Hoka.
What do podiatrists say about hiking footwear?
Podiatrists generally recommend hiking shoes with a wide toe box, a contoured insole with arch support, a low heel-to-toe drop (under 8mm), and enough cushioning to absorb trail shock without compressing over time. HOKA’s APMA-accepted Anacapa 2 is often cited for foot pain. Merrell’s Moab 3 is also frequently recommended by podiatrists for its contoured Kinetic Fit insole and roomy toe box.
Is Salomon or Merrell better?
Both are top-tier hiking shoe brands and the right pick depends on your foot shape. Salomon (X Ultra 5) has a narrower forefoot and a Quicklace system that does not work for everyone. Merrell (Moab 3) has a wider, roomier toe box and traditional laces that fit most foot shapes. If you have narrow to medium feet and want maximum agility, Salomon. If you have medium to wide feet and want out-of-the-box comfort, Merrell.
What are the top 5 hiking shoes?
Based on testing, review volume, and user feedback: 1) Merrell Moab 3 (best overall), 2) Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II (best waterproof value), 3) Merrell Moab 3 Women’s (best for women), 4) Timberland White Ledge Mid (best mid-cut boot), 5) Skechers Relment-Pelmo (best for beginners). All five are widely available and consistently rated 4.4+ stars across tens of thousands of Amazon reviews.
Do I need waterproof hiking shoes?
You need waterproof hiking shoes if you hike in wet or snowy climates more than 30% of the year, cross streams frequently, or hike shoulder seasons in rainy regions. You do not need waterproof hiking shoes if you hike primarily in dry climates, summer conditions, or desert terrain – waterproof membranes trap heat and dry slowly. The Merrell Moab 3 comes in both waterproof (GTX) and non-waterproof versions.
Are trail running shoes good for hiking?
Trail running shoes work well for fast day hiking and thru-hiking because they are lighter and more agile than hiking shoes. The tradeoff is less protection, less durability, and less traction on technical terrain. For maintained trails under 10 miles, trail runners are a great choice. For rocky terrain, multi-day backpacking, or off-trail routes, a hiking shoe with a more protective upper and a stiffer midsole is the safer bet.
Are hiking shoes better than hiking boots?
Hiking shoes are better than hiking boots for most day hiking and light backpacking under 25 pounds. They are lighter, more agile, and dry faster. Hiking boots are better for heavy backpacking (30+ pounds), off-trail terrain, ankle support needs, and wet/muddy conditions where ankle security matters. The right choice depends on terrain, pack weight, and foot needs – there is no universal answer.
Final Verdict: Which Hiking Shoe Should You Buy?
If you buy one pair of hiking shoes this year, buy the Merrell Moab 3. It is the most comfortable, most proven, most consistently rated hiking shoe in this roundup – 15,000+ reviews averaging 4.6 stars, roomy toe box, recycled materials, and grip that works on every terrain I have tested it on.
If you hike in wet climates, the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II is the waterproof value winner. If you are a woman shopping for a hiking shoe that fits women’s feet properly, the Merrell Moab 3 Women’s is the clear pick. If you are a beginner on a real budget, the Skechers Relment-Pelmo or Columbia Crestwood will get you on the trail without breaking the bank. If you carry a heavy pack and want ankle support, the Timberland White Ledge Mid has earned its decades of reputation for a reason.
The best hiking shoes are the ones that fit your feet, match your terrain, and stay comfortable for the kind of miles you actually hike. Use this guide to narrow down the field, then use the comparison table above to make the final call. Every pair on this list is a winner in its category – you cannot make a bad choice, only a different one.